We’ve all seen those people who feel just too happy. You know the ones, always with the perfect, positive response even as the world is spiraling around them. When we talk about gratitude, that is not what we mean. Imagine how that would work while someone is in a hospital waiting room, phone in hand, scrolling past a post that says "Gratitude turns what we have into enough." She's been there six hours, her dad is in surgery and now this “positive” post is encouraging her to see that she has enough. Even through the heartache. She turns the phone face down on her knee and thinks, with total clarity: I will throw this phone across the room! And that is a completely justified response to such a tone deaf message in that moment.
If that landed a little close, you're in good company. Last week we wrote about the real benefits of a gratitude practice. This week we want to talk about the other side of it, which is what happens when gratitude gets used as a lid on everything else you're feeling.
What toxic positivity actually is
"Toxic positivity" is a casual term, not a diagnosis, but most of us know it when we feel it. It's "everything happens for a reason." It's "at least you still have your health." It's "just focus on the good." These platitudes usually come from someone who means well and wants the discomfort to go away, theirs as much as yours.
The trouble is the message underneath. Hear it enough times and it starts to say: your hard feelings are a problem, and you're doing this wrong if you still have them. For women who are already the steady ones, the planners, the people holding everyone else's stuff, that lands hard. You don't need one more voice telling you to be fine. You have plenty of those, and most of them live in your own head. So where is the line when positivity becomes toxic?
The difference between gratitude and a lid
Here's how we think about it with a bit of clarity. Real gratitude is noticing. Forced positivity is covering.
Noticing sounds like: "This week is brutal, and my neighbor dropped off soup." Covering sounds like: "This week is brutal, but I shouldn't complain because other people have it worse."
One acknowledges what's true while the other quietly argues with it. And arguing with how you feel tends to backfire. Pushing a feeling down rarely makes it leave. More often it gets louder, or it leaks out sideways: at your kids, at your inbox, at 3am. In the end, that is where the positivity has the potential to become toxic.
If you've spent years being the strong one, you may have a lifetime of practice at covering. A gratitude habit built on top of that just becomes another way to say "I'm fine." That's not what we're after. A practice that works in a hard season doesn't ask you to feel better. It asks you to notice a little more, and that's a much lower bar and a much more honest one. When you take the time to notice, you also take the opportunity to see things more clearly and appreciate the goodness, even in a hard season.
Two things can be true at once
This is the part we'd put on a sticky note. You can be grateful your mom is still here and exhausted from caring for her. You can love your job and dread Monday. You can be thankful for your kids and count the minutes until bedtime. You can miss someone terribly and be glad for the years you had.
Neither feeling cancels the other. Nothing about a gratitude practice requires you to subtract the hard stuff. It's a "both/and," not an "instead of." The moment it turns into "instead of," it stops helping and starts sounding like a lecture, and we all know that isn’t helpful when you are facing a challenging situation or hard season.
Think of the woman in that waiting room. She can be terrified for her dad and grateful the nurse brought her a blanket. The blanket doesn't fix anything; it just counts. Noticing that it counts is what keeps her from feeling like the whole day is made of nothing but fear while appreciating the kindness extended by another person in her very hard time.
What a hard-season practice looks like
Forget the list of ten things. When you're in it, the practice may need to shrink, and that's fine. A few ways to do that may look like:
Go smaller. Not "I'm grateful for my family." More like "the dog sat on my feet while I cried." Small and specific is easier to believe, and believing it is the whole point.
Name what held you up. Some days gratitude isn't about joy. It's about what got you through: the friend who texted, the hot shower, five minutes in the car with the radio on. Ask what helped today? instead of what am I thankful for? It's a gentler question, and it often lands in the same place.
Put the hard thing and the okay thing side by side. One line each. "Today was awful. The coffee was good." You're not tidying up the bad. You're just letting the okay thing sit next to it so it gets counted.
Give yourself a pass. If you open the notebook and nothing comes, close it. Skipping a day in a hard week isn't failing. It's reading the room, and your heart and mind deserve that just as much as the woman in the hospital waiting room.
When gratitude just feels impossible
Some seasons, it will. Grief, a diagnosis, a job loss, a relationship ending, plain old burnout. In those weeks, forcing it can feel insulting, and we'd rather you skip it than fake it.
If you want a toehold anyway, try something smaller than gratitude: noticing. Name one thing you can see, hear, or feel right now that's neutral or okay. A warm mug. A quiet room. Sun on the floor. You're not trying to feel thankful. You're just reminding yourself that this moment has a little solid ground in it.
If someone else hands you the lid
It happens. A well-meaning friend, a relative at the holiday table, a coworker with a quote. You don't owe anyone a debate. A few easy lines that keep the peace and keep your boundary:
- "Thanks. I'm working through it, and I'm okay with it being hard right now."
- "I know you mean well. What would help most is just having someone listen."
- "I'm holding both. It's a lot, and I'm grateful for the people who show up."
- “Thank you for caring. I’m not ready to talk about it quite yet.”
And if you're the one wanting to comfort someone else, try "that sounds really hard" before reaching for a silver lining. Nine times out of ten, it's what they needed first.
A word on getting support
A journal can keep you company, but it can't carry the whole load and offer supportive insights. If you've felt persistently down, anxious, numb, or hopeless for more than a couple of weeks, or if getting through the day feels like too much, please talk to a counselor. If you're ever thinking about harming yourself, you can call or text 988 anytime in the U.S. You don't have to hit your breaking point before you're allowed to ask for help.
If this is your season
If you're carrying something heavy right now, we hope this gave you permission to practice gratitude your own way, or to set it down for a while. Both are okay.
If you'd like a few prompts that make room for the harder days, the 30 Days of Gratitude Prompts includes several. [Download them here]
Infinite Healing — You Belong Here

